I have a '23 OBX with 25k miles. Mixed driving I average 24-25 mpg overall. Long trips I get 28-30mpg and driving back and forth to work (about 8 miles) I get 23-24mpg. For context, I use mid-grade octane (89-91) fuel.
Sponsored
It seems to vary more with the 1.5. I suppose it greatly depends on your driving conditions and styles. People have reported milage in the mid 20’s to the mid 30’s. The 2.0 seems to run low 20’s to high 20’s.2025 1.5L 2400 miles and I've never gotten more than 26.1 mpg