2021 Bronco Sport Badlands - will not shift out of park - intermittent

[DronesRefined]

Hello, I have a 2021 Ford Bronco Sport Badlands with approximately 70,000 miles purchased about 6 months ago. I've experienced an intermittent issue twice so far (this week and few weeks ago). The vehicle starts normally, but it will not shift into D. The round shifter just will not move and remains in P. On both occasions, I shut the vehicle off and returned about an hour later, and it started and shifted into D without any issues.

The vehicle otherwise drives and shifts normally since purchase, and there are no warning lights, check engine lights, or other indications of a problem.

The vehicle is still covered under its certified warranty, but I'm concerned that the dealership may not be able to diagnose the problem because they may be unable to duplicate the issue when they inspect it. I did take the video recording when it occurred this week as evidence, but still not sure if this is enough for Ford dealer to go on. I would appreciate any advice.

Sponsored

 

[rugedraw]

Do you have any kind of code scanner? If not and if the vehicle is connected to the Ford app, message me the VIN so I can pull the codes it is reporting. It could be a bad GSM (gear shift module).

 

[rugedraw]

Got your message, but responding here for the sake of the info being out there. In your case, the vehicle has not reported any codes related to your concern. These are the only codes in the cloud, and all these are stored codes and not active faults that you need to be concerned about. Codes are stored for 90 days at a time, and I don't see anything related to the shifter, transmission or powertrain in the history that can be an contributing factor to the shifter not coming out of park.

Sorry, but in this case, I am not able to provide anything concrete, but it could be the GSM is about to take a crap.

 

[DronesRefined]

Thank you. The vehicle is certified and under warranty. Based on the video I took do you think Ford dealer would perform any repair without codes?

 

[rugedraw]

Thank you. The vehicle is certified and under warranty. Based on the video I took do you think Ford dealer would perform any repair without codes?

As a dealer employee, I highly doubt it. They would need a code or need to be able to replicate the issue while in their possession. You can try, but I would keep my expectations low.

 

[DronesRefined]

Yeah, that is what I thought. The crazy part about It I would need to tow it there, but by the time it gets there it might just shift without a problem, hate these kind of issues.

 

[rugedraw]

Yeah, that is what I thought. The crazy part about It I would need to tow it there, but by the time it gets there it might just shift without a problem, hate these kind of issues.

Well, if you can spare the car for a few days and you're gonna send it on a tow truck, that may be enough to get them to look at it even if it works as it should when it gets there. However, without a code or an actual issue, they aren't going to get very far unless upon physical inspection, there's something obviously wrong. It could very well end up being a wasted effort.

 

[DronesRefined]

Thanks, what a strange issue

 

[RSH]

Several different things can can effect the operation of the rotary gear selector.
1. Low battery voltage.
2. Bad brake light switch, do the brake lights come on when the brake pedal is depressed.
3. Safety interlock switch.
4. Bad or obstructed rotary gear selector mechanism/switch/module, has any liquid been spilled in the area around the rotary gear selector.
5. Sport parked on an incline binding up the transmission parking pawl.
Someone had a shifter issue a while back that was caused by having a hair scrunchie wrapped around the gear selector.

Surprised it has not registered any codes.
The dealer should be able to figure out the problem, they have access to more information.

 

[Garth]

Check your door switches etc, I know there are safeties that wont let you engage the transmission and if one of them is malfunctioning it may not send a code because it thinks its doing its job. Maybe your hood latch or others, Im not sure of all of them.

 

[incavulator]

I would think they would still investigate, but in their defense, it's going to be hard to fix without the problem being present when they look at it.

I wonder if it could be related to an intermittent brake switch or the brake-shift interlock issue?

I suggest you try this now while it's working and then do the same thing the next time the issue occurs.......

Start the vehicle and while sitting in park with radio/HVAC off (so you can hear) press lightly on the brake pedal while holding your hand on the rotary shifter. You should feel/hear a click when you press the brake pedal down and then again if you release the brake pedal.

This is the brake-shift interlock device operating. When the problem occurs, I'm betting you won't feel/hear that interlock engaging/disengaging. If you can get the problem to occur, have someone check to see if the brake lights are working when you are pressing and releasing the pedal. If not, it's likely a brake switch malfunction. If they are working, I'm guessing it's likely the brake shift interlock, which is probably integral to the shifter.

Either way, I think this info would be helpful for the technicians.

 

[kenmitch]

They say a photos worth a thousand words, videos must be worth millions? Going by what you said it sounds like you'd have time to make a video as proof of intermittent failure. If you do video it make sure you do some talking, show doors closed, dash panel with no warnings, foot on brake pedal, and of course trying to shift out of park. The downside would be it won't show the cause, just the effect, but at least it'll be enough to show that there is an issue with the system.

 

[Dude]

… message me the VIN

Just curious .. with the VIN are you able to access all Ford service department repair records for OPs 2021? Might show prior history for the gear selector, transmission or other related components

 

[rugedraw]

Just curious .. with the VIN are you able to access all Ford service department repair records for OPs 2021? Might show prior history for the gear selector, transmission or other related components

Good call. Just checked and all it shows is two recalls done; both requiring firmware updates to the BCM and PCM. Also shows the 12v battery replaced in April of 2025.......that's it. The previous owner did not have it serviced at a Ford dealer, but the Carfax shows it was very well maintained at a 3rd party shop in terms of routine oil changes and what not.

 

[Dude]

Good call. Just checked and all it shows is two recalls done; both requiring firmware updates to the BCM and PCM. Also shows the 12v battery replaced in April of 2025.......that's it. The previous owner did not have it serviced at a Ford dealer, but the Carfax shows it was very well maintained at a 3rd party shop in terms of routine oil changes and what not.

This is my inside voice but I’ll say it anyway… is there anything that prevents you from providing OP with the former owners contact info (assuming is in the documentation for the recall work) so that OP could contact the former owner and ask about known issues with the gear selector?

Sponsored