Think a paint-less dent repair service could do the trick? Then have a shop buff out the scuff mark from the puck? (Cant really tell the extent of the song from the photo)
Only reason I ask… I once had a car scuff the entire length of my wife’s car with their bumper. In my case there was no dent, but the rubber scuff mark peeled off in long strips….
Why guess, most any auto body shop will give you a free estimate, the paint less dent removal peeps will do the same. Hard to tell in the photo how dented the door is, the black mark/scuff is what initially calls your attention.