I got more than he offered, but a bit less than I thought I should have gotten. If it had been any other vehicle, I probably would have walked out. Mainly due to the manager's attitude. Bottom line, I'm ok with the way it turned out and I love my OB. Been poring over the manual this evening.How did it end up? I walked in to the dealer with an offer from Vroom to purchase my Forester for $2k more than Carmax. Dealer told me he couldn't touch it so I sold it to Vroom. I hate games dealers play.