I think it has more to do with thigh length and what you're used to. I'm a 6'3" @ 195 and I'm perfectly comfortable with my Badlands driver seat. My wife is 5'4" and is fine with the passenger seat.The seats are probably great if you are 5’5” however if you are 6’2” @ 250lbs it’s like travelling on a bar stool. After the windshield glass, this is number 2 on my list of dislikes! If you have not had a crack in your your windshield yet.. it’s coming!